Best Italian Restaurants in Huntsville, Ontario

10 Best Italian Restaurants in Huntsville, Ontario in 2023

In this blog, we’ll take you on a gastronomic journey through Huntsville as we explore the 10 Best Italian Restaurants in Huntsville, Ontario in 2023 that are sure to satisfy your craving for authentic Italian flavors.

Huntsville, Ontario, nestled in the heart of Muskoka, is renowned for its stunning natural beauty and outdoor activities. However, it’s not just the scenic landscapes that draw visitors to this charming town; it’s also the delectable Italian cuisine offered by its top-notch restaurants. Whether you’re a local resident or a tourist exploring the region, you’re in for a culinary treat.

Here is a List of 10 Best Italian Restaurants in Huntsville, Ontario in 2023

Spencer’s Tall Trees Restaurant

Nestled among the tall trees of Muskoka, Tall Trees Restaurant offers an Italian dining experience like no other. With its rustic charm and picturesque setting, it’s the perfect place for a romantic dinner or special celebration.

Try their homemade pasta dishes, such as fettuccine alfredo and lobster ravioli, for an unforgettable taste of Italy.

3 Guys And A Stove

3 Guys And A Stove is a culinary gem in Huntsville, known for its creative and eclectic menu. While not strictly Italian, this restaurant offers Italian-inspired dishes that are simply divine.

Don’t miss their wood-fired pizzas with toppings like prosciutto and arugula, or their rich and savory risotto. The inventive flavors and cozy atmosphere make it a must-visit.

That Little Place by the Lights

Tucked away in downtown Huntsville, That Little Place by the Lights is a local favorite for Italian cuisine. This cozy spot is perfect for a casual meal with friends or family.

Their pizzas are a standout, with a variety of toppings and a perfectly crispy crust. The homemade lasagna and chicken parmesan are also highly recommended.

The Mill on Main

The Mill on Main offers a beautiful blend of Italian and Canadian cuisine in a historic setting. Located in a former lumber mill, the restaurant combines old-world charm with modern tastes.

Try their pasta dishes, like linguine with clams and mussels, or indulge in a classic veal piccata. The Mill’s elegant ambiance is ideal for special occasions.

Simply Cottage

Simply Cottage, while primarily known for its cottage decor, also houses a delightful cafe offering Italian-inspired dishes. The cafe’s charming setting overlooking Fairy Lake adds to the dining experience.

Try their hearty paninis, like the Caprese with fresh mozzarella and basil, or savor their flavorful pasta dishes.

The Cottage Waterfront Grill

For a taste of Italy by the water, head to The Cottage Waterfront Grill. This restaurant boasts a beautiful lakeside location, making it a popular choice for locals and visitors alike.

Their menu features Italian-inspired seafood dishes, including linguine with white wine garlic sauce and seafood risotto, all prepared with a touch of Mediterranean flair.

Casa Rustica

Casa Rustica is a hidden gem that brings the warmth of Italian hospitality to Huntsville. The cozy interior and friendly staff create a welcoming atmosphere.

Try their traditional spaghetti and meatballs or go for the pizza with a thin, crispy crust. Don’t forget to sample their tiramisu for a sweet finish to your meal.

Trattoria Gusto

Trattoria Gusto offers a genuine taste of Italy in the heart of Huntsville. With a menu crafted from fresh, locally sourced ingredients, this restaurant showcases the best of Italian cuisine.

Savor their wood-fired pizzas, handmade pasta dishes, and an impressive selection of Italian wines. The romantic ambiance is perfect for a date night.

3 Guys and a Beer’d Brewing Company

While primarily known for its craft beers, 3 Guys and a Beer’d Brewing Company also serves up some Italian-inspired dishes that pair perfectly with their brews.

Try their beer-infused pizza or the beer-battered fish and chips for a unique twist on classic Italian flavors. It’s a casual spot for food and beer enthusiasts.

Algonquin Cafe

Algonquin Cafe is a quaint Italian eatery known for its homely atmosphere and authentic flavors. The menu features a variety of pasta dishes, including creamy carbonara and spicy arrabbiata.

Locals rave about their homemade meatballs and hearty minestrone soup. It’s the kind of place where you feel like family.


Huntsville, Ontario, offers more than just breathtaking natural landscapes; it also serves up a delightful array of Italian cuisine that will transport your taste buds straight to Italy.

Whether you prefer traditional pasta dishes, wood-fired pizzas, or inventive Italian-inspired creations, these 10 restaurants have something for every Italian food lover.

So, take a break from outdoor adventures and immerse yourself in the rich and delicious world of Italian dining in Huntsville. Buon appetito!

Most Important Cities of United States

1 Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *